Cookie Cutter Adoption?

by | May 19, 2016 | Adoptive Families Blog

Open Adoption With One Birth Mother,
Semi-Open With Another?

cookie_cutter_adoption.jpgDear Mardie,

We are ready to adopt again, but this time, we do not want to be as open to birth mother contact.  Specifically, we do not want to be open to visits. Our daughter’s birth mother had specified that she only wanted pictures and letters. We wouldn’t want one child to have visits with a birth mother and not the other – it would just seem unfair and maybe confusing.  Is that okay?

I have heard this from many parents over the years.  They want a situation very similar to their first adoption, so the children have more things in common and there are less differences to explain.

Let me let you in on a little secret… there are always differences you have to explain, even when you plan for there not to be.

Consider Joseph and Megan, they have two adopted children from Lifetime and both birth parents agreed to exchange pictures and letters.  Dawn, their son’s birth mother, kept in touch two or three times a year for the first five years.  Mostly, she just received the updates that Megan sent to Dawn’s mother’s home.  Dawn would respond with a note now and then, but her life wasn’t particularly stable.  The last update they got from Dawn said that her mother had passed away and she would write with a new address for the updates when she had one.  Four years have gone by and they haven’t heard a word from her. 

Sarah and Jake, their daughter’s birth parents, also receive pictures and letters from Joseph and Megan, but eagerly respond with updates from their own life, including photos of them and their younger children.  They send birthday and Christmas gifts to their daughter and to Joseph and Megan.  A few years after the adoption, Sarah and Jake got married and shared in their wedding program how going through adoption for their daughter was difficult, but it brought them together in a way nothing else could.  They shared a copy of this with Joseph and Megan for their daughter’s baby book so she could one day see more of their story. 

In light of those differences in the results of what ‘letters and pictures’ are in the real world, see what Joseph and Megan have to explain to their children? Why one gets gifts from birth parents that the other does not? Why one has more of a ‘story’ to her adoption than the other? Why one child’s birth parents chose to stay in touch and another didn’t?  Even when you try to make all things equal, they rarely are.

As a follow up, Megan mentioned once in an update to Sarah that she sure wished their son’s birth mother was in touch still, but they just don’t hear from her.  From then on, Sarah would always include a little note and gift for their son too, reminding him he is special and a part of their family too, just like his sister.

Everyone has their own story, and it is our job as parents to be sensitive to our child’s needs and share information at an age appropriate level.  Children’s first thoughts are usually about themselves, so have limited cares or concerns about birth parents. It isn’t until a child is older that they become more aware and may become more inquisitive. 

Just because Dawn no longer keeps in touch with Joseph and Megan, doesn’t mean that she doesn’t care about her son. Similarly, just because Sarah and Jake do stay in touch, doesn’t mean they love their daughter more.  They are just different people, with different needs and in different circumstances. 

Think of your own circle of friends…  Maybe you have one who is a planner and always inviting you somewhere, another who tends to cancel last minute, and still another one who is so busy with her job and family that she can rarely do anything.  Look at your Facebook feed…  Some of your friends there post their morning coffee, others detail every stop on the carpool, and others maybe post something once a week that is simply shared content.  

We are all different.  All adoptions are different.  And when I speak with a family who wants to limit their preferences to try to make things the same, I strongly encourage them against it.  Like Megan and Joseph, you can have two similar scenarios with completely different outcomes.  In adoption, flexibility will always serve you well.

There are many, many more differences that can arise in similar adoptions, such as differences in appearance, in talents, in medical needs, and so much more! 

Find your level of comfort with contact, and go with that.  Please don’t restrict your preferences simply in hopes that you will have cookie cutter adoptions. As much as they may seem alike, there will always be differences!

Mardie Caldwell, C.O.A.P.

Written by Mardie Caldwell, C.O.A.P.

Founder of Lifetime Adoption, adoptive mom, adoption expert, and Certified Open Adoption Practitioner (C.O.A.P).

Since 1986, adoption expert Mardie Caldwell has been dedicated to bringing couples and birth parents together in order to fulfill their dreams.

“Many years ago, I was also searching for a child to adopt. We didn’t know where or how to get started. Through research, determination, and a prayer, our dream of a family became reality. I started with a plan, a notebook, assistance from a caring adoption consultant and a lot of hard work; this was my family I was building. We had a few heartaches along the way, but the pain of not having children was worse!

Within weeks we had three different birth mothers choose us. We were overwhelmed and delighted. Many unsettling events would take place before our adoption would be finalized, many months later. Little did I know that God was training and aligning me for the adoption work I now do today. It is my goal to share with our families the methods and plans which succeed and do not succeed. I believe adoption should be affordable and can be a wonderful “pregnancy” for the adoptive couple.

I have also been on both sides of infertility with the loss of seven pregnancies and then conceiving by new technology, giving birth to a healthy daughter. I have experienced first-hand the emotional pain of infertility and believe my experience allows me to serve your needs better.

It is my hope that for you, the prospective parents, your desire for a child will be fulfilled soon.”

Read More About Mardie Caldwell

Get the latest adoption news, tips, and guidance straight to your inbox!


You may also like…

How to Find a Birth Parent-focused Adoption Professional

How to Find a Birth Parent-focused Adoption Professional

An indication of an ethical adoption agency is what sort of birth parent support they provide. Choosing adoption for their child is one of the most painful decisions in a birth parent’s life. An ethical adoption agency knows this and keeps the best interests of birth...

What if There Are Two Types of Adoption in One Family?

What if There Are Two Types of Adoption in One Family?

Open adoption arrangements vary from situation to situation. They can range from sharing little information to having a lot of future contact and involvement. As you embark on this path, it’s important to recognize that each adoption is unique, especially for open...

Looking for Adoption Agencies? 6 Important Questions to Ask

Looking for Adoption Agencies? 6 Important Questions to Ask

Many people search for “adoption agencies near me” or "adoption agency near me," but that may not be nearly as important as asking the right questions. The adoption professional or agency you hire will impact your entire adoption experience. Your adoption agency will...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest